Migrants who pay the Immigration Health Surcharge (IHS) – a fee paid by most visa holders for their use of the NHS – are likely to use significantly less NHS care than they effectively pay for. [1]
- The IHS has grown by 400%, from a £200 annual charge intended as a contribution towards migrants’ health care costs, to a £1,035 annual charge intended to cover costs entirely (£776 for students and child dependents). When factoring in normal tax contributions, new analysis by the Nuffield Trust finds that those paying the IHS contributed at least 60% more to the NHS budget in 2023/24 than DHSC’s estimate of their health care costs for the same financial year. [2]
- The analysis stands in contrast to the common belief that migrants cause a drain on the health service. In fact, people who pay the health surcharge are significant net contributors to the NHS’s financial resources.
The authors raise concerns about the strength of the evidence underpinning the DHSC’s estimate of average health care costs for IHS payers, which is used to determine the surcharge rate. This suggests that the surcharge itself may be set too high.
The analysis also warns that declining immigration threatens to further destabilise already precarious NHS finances. If immigration numbers are reduced significantly in future years – as a number of political parties have pledged – the health service is set to miss out on hundreds of millions of pounds raised by the IHS, as it has become a significant funding stream:
- The IHS brought in £150-250 million a year from migrants across the UK between 2015 and 2018. Income from the IHS then rose sharply after the surcharge rate increased and immigration grew, peaking at almost £2.5 billion in 2024/25.
- This means that revenue from the IHS has increased tenfold as a share of the NHS budget over a decade (up from 0.1% in 2015/16 to more than 1% of the entire NHS budget in 2024/25).
- IHS income fell by over £100 million as immigration declined, to £2.3bn in the year to 2025/26. The surcharge remains a significant source of income for the NHS, so further falls in immigration could negatively affect NHS finances.
Despite its growing importance, the IHS is an unstable funding stream, owing to its reliance on immigration flows and the way that the money is received and spent. Instead of spreading the cost across multiple years, migrants are required to pay the IHS for the entire duration of their visa (typically three years) upfront as one lump sum, which is then transferred to and spent by the NHS in the first year. The authors of the analysis argues that the current practice of transferring the entire surcharge fee to the NHS in one year – even where the fee might represent three years’ worth of charge - makes the stability of the NHS’s finances vulnerable to future falls in migration numbers.
Nuffield Trust Fellow, Stelios Vassiliou, said:
“Whether by accident, by design, or a combination of the two, the Immigration Health Surcharge has grown to a prominence that cannot be ignored. If the level of income from the charge was to fall back to that seen at its inception in 2015/16, the NHS would be left facing a shortfall in the billions, as it has grown reliant on immigrants in this group contributing substantially more to the NHS than they take out. Our analysis should give politicians pause for thought about this unforeseen, and possibly overlooked, consequence of changes to visa rules.
“With around a fifth of the NHS workforce hailing from overseas, it’s well understood that immigration affects NHS staffing. This analysis shines a light on migrant contributions to our health service that receive far less attention.
“The government needs to think carefully about what it’s trying to achieve with the surcharge. We need clarity on whether this policy is about migrants paying their fair share, topping up NHS funding, or discouraging migration in the first place.”
Notes to editors
A copy of the full analysis is available here.
- The IHS applies to visas lasting over 6 months in the UK. Some exemptions apply for those seeking asylum, those on humanitarian visas, those on the health and social care visa route and some other exemptions detailed here.
- The analysis compares the contributions of visa holders in different scenarios (taking account of both the IHS and direct taxes) with the 2023 DHSC calculation that the average use of health care by IHS payers was £1,036 a year. Using data for 2023/24, it finds that:
- An individual with no dependents on a skilled worker Visa earning £55,000 may have contributed 511% more than the DHSC’s calculated cost of their NHS care.
- An individual on a skilled worker visa earning £55,000 bringing dependents (two children and an adult working part-time earning £15,000) may have contributed 125% more than the calculated cost of NHS care for the group of four.
- An individual on an international student visa may have contributed 25% less than the calculated cost of their NHS care
- An individual on a post-study work visa may have contributed 120% more than the calculated cost of their NHS care.
- The IHS cohort contributed at least 60% more towards the NHS budget than the DHSC’s estimate of their health care costs in that same financial year.